What Is the Best Mascara for Length

What Is the Best Mascara for Length/ Volume/Sensitive Eyes?

With mascaras becoming increasingly popular, they’ve also become more specialized. As a result, some are better at elongating lashes, while others are better at making them look thicker.

Given all of the choices and benefits of different types of mascaras, it can be difficult to know what to get. For example, what is the best mascara for length, volume, and sensitive eyes?

Well, there are a few options on the market that are better than others. After extensive research, we are excited to bring you our top 5 picks along with descriptions, pros and cons, and important considerations.

The 5 Best Mascaras For Length/Volume/Sensitive Eyes

As you might expect, some mascaras are better at specific things than others. That’s because one mascara might specialize in eyelash volume, while another might be chemically designed to accommodate mascara-wearers with sensitive eyes.

Here, we take the time to describe the specific benefits of each of our top 5 picks.

1. Gaya Cosmetics Vegan Mascara

The Gaya Cosmetics Vegan Mascara may be the best mascara for volume on the market thanks to its curved wand, which allows for greater control. There are also many other reasons why we love this product.

In addition to securing you the volume you long for, this mascara has also been thoroughly tested and is safe for people with sensitive eyes.

This means that you shouldn’t have any issues with the mascara irritating your eyes. You won’t have to worry about the mascara negatively affecting your contact lenses or your eyes getting watery.

Like its name would suggest, it’s also cruelty-free and friendly, so animal lovers rave about this mascara.

However, there are some negatives. The most notable of these is that the wand isn’t as firm as some people would prefer. As a result, the mascara can smear when you’re applying it.

If you’re careful, though, this shouldn’t be too much of an issue. This may mean that you’ll need a little bit more time getting ready as you’re getting used to this mascara wand, though.


  • Thoroughly tested for sensitive eyes and people who wear contact lenses.
  • Curved wand helps bring more volume control.
  • Vegan-friendly and cruelty-free.


  • Tends to smear.


2. Fifth & Skin NATURLASH Mascara

After all of our research, we found the Fifth & Skin NATURLASH to be the best mascara for sensitive eyes on the market today. The main reason for this is its hypoallergenic formula, which ensures that no toxins are used.

As a result, there are no ingredients included that could set off your eyes, meaning you can enjoy wearing mascara without any discomfort. While that’s the largest benefit to this mascara, there are also a few others.

One intriguing selling point is that it can also be used as a liquid eyeliner, so you wouldn’t have to buy it separately.

Furthermore, even though this mascara is water-resistant, it can be removed easily with soap and warm water. This can be done relatively quickly, so there’s not going to be much removal time involved.

It’s worth noting, though, that it’s water-resistant and not waterproof. It also tends to smear if you’re not careful when you’re applying it. If you take your time with it, though, this shouldn’t be an issue.


  • Hypoallergenic formula means it can be used on sensitive eyes.
  • While water-resistant, it can be taken off easily with soap and water.
  • Can also double as a liquid eyeliner.


  • It can smear if you’re not careful when applying.


3. Honest Beauty Extreme Length Mascara

We believe Honest Beauty has created the best mascara for length with this product, as it provides one of the higher lifts on the market.

It also comes with a handful of other notable benefits. Surprisingly, this mascara can also double as a primer, which will help save time when you’re getting ready.

The bristles have been designed to give your eyelashes as much definition as possible. As a result, your eyelashes aren’t just going to be long, but they’ll take on the desired shape and style so that you look great with long lashes.

Unfortunately, while you might be able to save time when applying this Honest Beauty Extreme Length mascara, you may lose some of that while waiting for it to dry. Because of this, some reviews mention that it has a habit of clumping.


  • Also works as a primer to save time when you’re getting ready.
  • Bristles have been engineered to expertly define your lashes.
  • Provides a much higher lift than other mascaras.


  • Can clump and will take a while to dry.


4. Tetyana Naturals 4D Silk Fiber Lash Mascara

The Tetyana Naturals 4D Silk Fiber Lash Mascara is definitely one of the best mascaras for length available today. This is thanks to a whole host of benefits, with the length being just the tip of the iceberg.

Chief among these features is that it’s a long-lasting mascara, with one coating lasting almost all day. Furthermore, with its non-toxic formula, it’s a great option for sensitive eyes.

It also won’t smudge when you’re applying it or clump up while you’re waiting for it to dry. This makes for a stress-free application process.

However, this is one of the few long-lasting mascaras that isn’t waterproof or water-resistant. As a result, it may start to clump and come off if you happen to get caught in the rain or wear this mascara during a sweaty workout.

Thankfully, a quick wash and reapplication should fix this, although that can be a bit inconvenient.


  • Lashes look longer than they would with alternatives from competitors.
  • One coating should last the whole day.
  • Non-toxic formula makes it great for sensitive eyes.
  • Doesn’t clump, flake, or smudge.


  • Isn’t waterproof and may come off in chunks when exposed to rain, sweat, or other moisture.


5. Fifth & Skin Better’n Ur Lashes Organic Mascara

When it comes to the best mascara for sensitive eyes, few can match Fifth & Skin’s Better’n Ur Lashes Organic Mascara. As the name would suggest, the natural formula means that it isn’t going to agitate your eyes.

It’s also hypoallergenic, so it also won’t set off any allergies you’ll have. The non-toxic nature of the formula also means that it’s much healthier for your lashes than others.

Naturally, this means that your eyelashes will stay healthier for much longer than they would with other products. Additionally, there is one other benefit that you may be surprised by.

Once the first coating has dried, you can add a second layer to add even more length. This could make it much more appealing than some of its competitors.

Given the price of the mascara and the fact that the bottle is noticeably smaller than many similarly-priced products, some customers feel that they aren’t getting their money’s worth. Some say they end up going through a bottle much faster than they’d anticipated.


  • Doesn’t use toxic chemicals, so it won’t negatively affect your lashes.
  • Hypoallergenic, so it is great for sensitive eyes.
  • Can be double-coated for even longer lashes.


  • The bottle is smaller than many similarly-priced competitors.


What to Look for When Buying the Best Mascara for Length/Volume/Sensitive Eyes

Naturally, there are quite a few things that you’ll need to consider when buying mascara. The first of these is the type of wand it has, as these can come in different shapes. Different wand styles come with unique benefits.

For example, a pointed brush can have more precision than a skinny brush, which is often better for evenly applying mascara. Naturally, you’ll want to consider each of these shapes and their benefits before making a decision.

You’ll also want to think about whether or not you want waterproof mascara. While this can have its benefits, it can be quite hard to remove and damaging to your eyelashes.

Finally, consider whether or not it’s long-lasting; after all, you wouldn’t want to keep reapplying throughout the day.

While it may feel challenging to choose the best mascara, your taste and mascara requirements should not be overlooked. Once you find the right mascara for you, your eyelashes will look amazing for quite some time.


When it comes to the question of what is the best mascara for length, volume, and sensitive eyes, it can be a difficult one to answer. To name our overall top pick, however, it would have to be the Tetyana Naturals 4D Silk Fiber Lash Mascara.

While it does have some drawbacks, especially when wet, the pros far outweigh the cons. This is especially true when considering the price, and with how affordable it is, it’s definitely worth trying at least once to see how much you’ll love it.

However, if you’re not looking for length, but you instead want the best mascara for sensitive eyes, then we highly recommend the Fifth & Skin NATURLASH.

Which mascara is your favorite? Let us know in the comments!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *